So as you may have read already, Steve Carell won an award Sunday night at the Television Critics Association Awards, and he gave a hilarious acceptance speech in which he recited a long passage of a review of his performance on the Tim Curry sitcom "Over the Top," which aired on ABC, as Carell put it, "from October 1997 to ... October 1997."
There's a point in the review where you assume it has to be fake:
I have stood in a freezer full of dead people at the morgue. I have
seen a man’s scalp pulled back over his nose. I’ve even seen 35 minutes
of Ellen DeGeneres’s “Mr. Wrong.” But I can now honestly say that until
Steve Carell’s turn in the premiere of Over the Top, I have never known true horror.
Over the top, indeed. And then I went back to my room, googled the show, and discovered not only was the review real, it had appeared in none other than the electronic pages of TeeVee.org, one of the oldest TV-review sites on the web and a longtime partner-in-crime of TV Barn.
I giddily emailed my pal Jason Snell, editor of TeeVee, and he wrote back:
The author of that review is, amusingly enough, now a U.S.
Attorney in San Diego. And indeed, he has seen those horrors.
Jason also passed along a copy of an email he got after the review appeared:
I would like to congratulate you on your Review of Over the Top. That is some good writing.
Stephen Colbert
The Daily Show
Which naturally raises the question: Was that the real Colbert writing, or the fake one?