« Katie Couric, the compact version | Main | The delightful Simon Baker »

July 16, 2006

Comments

Marshall Letcher

Because the Sci Fi Channel is not available in Canada, we downtrodden sci-fi fans in Vancouver will not be able to watch “Eureka” - even though it is filmed locally. Blah!

Aaron

A reader writes:

Your reference to Los Alamos in a review of a new TV show indicates a stunning lack of understanding of the events of that moment in World history. If you are going to use throw away lines in an attempt to revise history, for those that are to lazy to do their own research, at least state your comment comes from personal bias and/or a complete ignorance of the facts.

As a veteran who witnessed the sacrifices of many to allow the freedom of speech you choose to abuse I cannot tell you how deeply this offends me. I don't want to restrict your freedom of speech, an important right worthy of defense, I would like to see it exercised with more responsibility and with due respect for the facts.

...

To which I replied:

Hi Jim. I am sorry that you disagree on my interpretation of the use of atomic force. However, simply because I disagree with your interpretation does not mean that your point of view is more fact-based than mine. By your measure, even J. Robert Oppenheimer himself would be considered "lazy" and "ignorant" -- two things I'm pretty sure he wasn't.

I also disagree with your comment that this represents an "abuse" of free speech -- that sounds like something somebody would say just before taking someone else's free speech away.

...

To which he replied:

I don't know who I am writing to that speaks on behalf of Aaron Barnhardt. It appears that the only facts you recognize are the ones that might support your opinion. Mr. Oppenheimer was, as anyone responsible for the taking of human life (in this case many), tormented with the moral and ethical questions. He did at the end of the day make a great contribution to freedom around the World as evidenced by the fact that we are communicating in English rather than German or Japanese and that neither one of us is fearful of being arrested or executed for our position. He also lost his security clearance later in life as a result of some of his activities and views and his association with Communists.

I suspect while you accuse me of wanting to take away your free speech , you are a person that has made no personal sacrifice to protect that right for yourself or others. Freedom isn't free and the cost is higher than you can ever imagine and it is not possible for me to correctly describe it in mere words. War is a horrible thing and the reason you have been protected from experiencing it has much to do with hard decisions made by brave people with a wider vision of the consequences of doing nothing. In a World of madmen with visions of our demise, anything that makes us appear weak invites them to attack. Your words and position bring comfort to these people, I doubt that is your intent but that is the result.

I stand by my earlier comments and hope that rather than responding as if attacked, you will go seek the complete set of facts not just the ones you were spoon fed in school. Good luck

...

Yes, because he certainly didn’t respond at all like he’d been attacked ...

Soonerthought

So...lemme get this straight: you only deserve free speech in this country if you have fought in a war? Oh please. Sacrifice for freedom is not limited to battlefield exploits, as honorable as those are. Sacrifice means many things. What about Peace Corps members? What about people who volunteer in their communities? Are those of us who never wore a uniform less equal than those who have? Aaron, seems to me that your corresponding reader has a pretty narrow definition of what being a citizen means.

trudy

What is a real turn off about Eureka is Carter's being a sexist pig. Good for Lupo letting his jacket fall on the ground. And his attitude permeates the byplay with Allison. Ick. Hard to watch a show when the main character stinks and is always trying to degrade women.

jennifer

Sacrifice is fighting in a just war. Fighting in something like Vietnam or Iraq is a disgrace. Yeah, I really value the opinion of the guys and gals running Abu Ghraib or Guantanamo.

jennifer

Here's an example of the US bringing democracy to Iraq. Scroll down to the middle of the page:

http://www.tbrnews.org/Archives/a2376.htm#001

DonBoy

Was there a huge piece of sloppiness in the edit last night? They set up the thing with Zoe seeing another self, Dad and car go by, but nothing at the other end of the show. Presumably there was a version in which they're sent out of Eureka and shifted back in time so they won't be late, or something, but it got taken out, but the setup left in? Or did I blink?

The comments to this entry are closed.

TV Barn on Twitter:








Site design by A.B. with help from Julio Garcia | About KansasCity.com | Terms of Use/Privacy | Copyright | RSS | Contact