When I previewed “Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip” for attendees of
“Watch the Pilots with Aaron” at Screenland Theatre earlier this month, they
burst into applause. And that was before I showed it to them.
Such has been the anticipation for “Studio 60,” the latest project
from “West Wing” creator Aaron Sorkin and Thomas Schlamme. They left
“The West Wing” three years ago, Sorkin to write a political movie,
Schlamme to create a high-concept drama series called “Jack and Bobby”
that died in obscurity on the WB network.
If you like prime-time television, then you can only hope that some
order has been restored to the universe with “Studio 60,” a fast-paced
hour that takes place behind the scenes of a venerable but creatively
troubled late-night variety show that is meant to invite comparisons to
the real “Saturday Night Live.”
Yet after watching two episodes, which were quite enjoyable, I'm
afraid Sorkin and Schlamme haven't recaptured the magic. The world has
changed since “West Wing” signed on, not just because of those fateful
numbers 9-11 but another number, “24,” and three letters, “CSI.”
“The West Wing” spanned two presidencies and was always able to
project itself as a pleasant fantasy against the backdrop of real life.
The Bartlet White House was a place where men and women of integrity
briskly and efficiently conducted business while never seeming to lose
grasp of the public's interest, even (gasp) at times putting it above
their own.
“At its heart, 'Studio 60' is the same thing that 'The West Wing'
was at its heart and the same thing 'Sports Night' before that was at
its heart,” Sorkin told TV critics this summer. “It's about a group of
people committed to professionalism, committed to each other, committed
to what they're doing.”
But “Studio 60” is about more than that, and if you'll allow me to
mildly spoil the first 15 minutes of tonight's episode, I'll explain
how, and why it doesn't work for me.